Tool: The Grudge Meaning
The Grudge Lyrics
Of negativity
Calculate what you will
Will not tolerate
Desperate to control
All and everything
Unable to forgive
Your scarlet letterman
Clutch it like a cornerstone
Otherwise it all comes down
Justify...
-
1TOP RATED
#1 top rated interpretation:This album goes along with qabala and the tree of the sephirot. Which is on the back of the album case I believe, I don't have it right off hand here. This song is about the tenth path malchut (the kingdom). "wear the grudge like a crown."
malchut is the beginning of personality and the physical body or the foundation, found in the lyrics "clutch it like a corner stone, otherwise it all falls down."
this is also where the soul is united with source, this is the beginning of separating desire, the urge to individuate. I believe in the first half of this song this is where they are describing the feelings and thoughts they had early on in life. They also repeat a couple of these things near the end. (I am not gonna try and figure out what every single line means, if you want to know more go get a book on qabala and read about the 10th path you might find better answers in it then I did).
Saturn's placement at birth influences the person's work in life, their obstacles, the challenges that will test them and build character. Saturn shows how a person will mature, and how they will learn to cope with adversity.
Saturn has a 28 year cycle through the 12 zodiak signs. Spending about 2 years in each sign. When saturn is in your sign it faces you will many tests on your inner self. Having to do with some people mid life chrisis. It will also come when you are 55-60. And when saturn comes around you will either be lifted to a higher state of consciousness (not saying its gonna be christ concousness)or you will be hurt by these tests and be put further back.
Ok one more thing and I'll stop "these leaden grudges into gold" talking about hard work turning the hard lead heart into something great.
If you have read this far thank you, I could have missed some things I kinda rushed this cause half way through writing this my computer messed up and I had to rewrite it... But like I said if you want to know more go read up on qabala (there are a lot of ways to spell it) Im positive that this song is about the 10th path, not saying it isn't about more or could be about other things also, and I know this album is about the tree of life and every song pointing to a different path. This song is about saturn and the challenges it faces you with. And for those of you who thought this song was about a grudge Maynard has with someone... He isn't that straight forward about anything so usually the most obvious answer is not what he was intending the song to mean.
And one more thing yes I know they mean us to interpret the songs how we see or feel them, but they did write these songs with something in mind and did write it about something, so you can take this song any way you want and you won't be wrong. -
2TOP RATED
#2 top rated interpretation:This song is about people who hold grudges against other people. It's about how holding a grudge will only bring negativity to everyone involved, you included. If you are holding a grudge, you are just trying to control the situation (Calculate what you will/Will not tolerate).
If you refuse to forgive, then you are never going to grow.
"Give away the stone
Let the ocean take and transmutate
This cold and fated anchor
Give away the stone
Let the waters kiss and transmutate
These leaden grudges into gold."
The "stone" or "anchor" is the grudge, if you give it up, it can turn into something beautiful and valuable (not $$$).
Not to sound emo, but this song helped me when my girlfriend broke up with me. It taught me that to grow from our experiences, we must learn to forgive and move on, otherwise, we may drown. Now, I am a better person than I was. In relation to the song I was transformed, by the ultimate alchemists (Tool), from a hateful, depressed, sinking boulder, into a golden pheonix, risen from my own ashes. -
3TOP RATED
#3 top rated interpretation:I agree with most of the posts, this song is obviously about the dangers of holding a grudge. Someone wrote something about the scarlet lettermen being a reference to the Bible being written in red ink. I don't think that's quite right. There is a book called The Scarlet Letter. In the book, all who were convicted of commiting adultury were required to where a large red letter "A" on their chests. Go with the whole grudge idea... Unable to forgive your scarlet lettermen. It could well read, unable to forgive those who are adulterous. Or maybe, unable to forgive those whom everyone thinks is a horrible person. I am sure if I read the book again I could find something a little more relavant. I am sure it has something to do with the moral of that story. I am also sure that this was a heartfelt song and is probably a metaphor in general for holding a grudge against someone has done you wrong.
-
All of what you guys said AND perhaps he was describing a concept and using the imagery and metaphors to get the point across. Like other songs, it has many layers of meaning in addition to and in spite of how the meaning was intended by the original authors.
-
This song like many have stated is about holding grudges, it's also about spirituality, alchemy, hermetics and the Khaballah.
Simply put "Saturn ascends or comes round" is every 28-30 years when in astrology you cycle through the zodiac signs until you hit yours.
This happens every 28 years and usually comes with a midlife crisis or old age.
The choice you are left with when "Saturn Ascends" is to overcome your faults/ego/ grudges or refuse to change and suffer. That's what it means by
"Choose one or ten"
One = overcoming your faults and grudges/ego. This requires understanding of those you don't agree with. "Lifts you up like a child, light and innocent"
Ten = refusing to let go of that grudge, letting the ego win, desperate to control, "all and everything". Believing you can hold on to that grudge because you feel you are right and then "Saturn will drag you down like a stone, to consume you till you choose to let go"
Saturn ascending isn't by choice and it faces you with your faults, the idea is that you decide your own path and fate, you can't put blame on others for how you react. You forgive, take responsibility for your behavior, feelings and personal growth.
It's something you will be forced to face and you can choose to let go and have a better life with wisdom, understanding and love or be stubborn, suffer and become bitter.
-
Also when Saturn comes around again... in it's 30 year cycle... have you learned your lessons? Are you doomed to relive the same mistakes during the next 30 yr cycle? Have you let your grudges go? because if you don't, you choose the 10 and you're the fated anchor/ stone and your grudges are dragging you down like a stone. Choose the 1 and don't repeat your mistakes/ forgive your grudges and now they aren't holding you back from enlightenment / ascension... (Also like the spit you out like a child / chronos theme)
meybe bebe? -
If you watch the video (great vid) I personally take the songs as a symbol of how we are as humans operating under religion. If you see how the whole community ignores and scrutinizes as they blindly walk into the church. They sit in church and will hate who ever doesn't conform to him. When everyone goes home at then end of the day, they all have problems. (Judge not unless ye be judged thyself)
So they all hate the one guy because of following the pastures desires, and end up turning on each other. Simply put, making good others suffer because you are unable to think for yourself will ultimately destroy yourself.
I think it's a very accurate description of modern religion. It cause more damage to community then any good. The grudge would be the grudge held against the ones that don't use a pasture as a higher power. We don't need pastures to connect to God. -
It's about an episode of desperate housewives.
-
This song according to Maynard is about the anger one's spirit has after dying while in the midst of a goal. He said that it's about a cartel member in Arizona who had his head cut off and in retaliation and out of sheer anger and wrath, he stays until he can cut the head off of all involved in taking his head.
-
In simple terms the song is about the dangers of holding a grudge, even when you are in the 'right', when the healthy option is to let go and forgive.
Many have had a go at the Saturn reference but suba_357 was the only one to get close.
The Kabbalah Tree of Life is imagery used in several of Tools songs (Lateralus for one) as well as in album and stage artwork.
"Saturn ascends, the one, the ten"
Saturn (Binah, 3) represents reasoning and intelligence, or the awareness of the Grudge and the chance to make a decision to hold on to it or forgive.
"the one" (Kether) is ideal wisdom and is the choice to let go of the grudge
"the ten" (Malkuth) is the physical reality and represents the choice to keep holding the grudge because you are the one in the right, no matter the consequences.
On the tree of life "the one" is at the top and "the ten" is at the bottom which is referenced in the following lyrics (along with release from burden).
"Saturn comes back around
Lifts you up like a child
Or drags you down like a stone"
As someone pointed out adulterers were made to wear a Scarlet Letter so that all future actions are judged on their previous sins. Just as in the song the protagonist is judging all the actions of the person he holds the grudge against based on a past wrong.
This was meant to be a short interpretation funny how Tool makes that impossible. :) -
This interpretation has been marked as poor. view anyway
-
I like the dual themes of hanging on and letting go. Very alchemical.
-
Clever and beautiful song about alchemicaL philosophy.
So large in is scope, oridinary definitions can not wrap around this subject, Alchemy. This song is full Alchemy symbols and archtypes.
If you have studied THOTH, Hermetica, The Emerald Tablets, or Alchemy... even more of this song will be open to you. -
Where the grudge like a crown of negativity...unable to forgive your scarlet lettermen...
Matthew 27:28-29 (New International Version)
28They stripped him and put a scarlet robe on him, 29and then twisted together a crown of thorns and set it on his head. They put a staff in his right hand and knelt in front of him and mocked him. "Hail, king of the Jews!" they said. -
Has no one even thought that this song could be "poking fun" at astrology? I'm not going to go through the whole song but actually listen to lyrics and how maynard projects them. I'll start with the very beginning of the song. "wear the grudge like a crown" - take your astrological readings and "flaunt" them." "Calculate what we will and will not tolerate."-- this could relate in how astrologists give their "readings" on what we believe and hold fast to. "Desperate to control all and everything."-- could relate to people trying to control everything in their life.? "Unable to forgive these scarlett letterman."-- could be that people tend to believe in what the astrologist says and again holds fast to it... just think about it in that sense and see if it doesn't seem more plausible than your favorite band TOOL, who has been bashing organized religion since their debut, actually encouraging alchemy and astrology... come on guys
-
This song is all about holding a grudge and the dangers and destruction in doing so. Saturn is a grudge itself and when it orbits your mind, you might forget about it for a while, but it always comes back around for you to decide if you can let it go and start living, or let it eat you up again and bring you down, sinking deeper.
-
This song.. everytime I hear makes me feel a calamity... and tells you to let go... but at the same times reminds you of those grudges... and makes you feel anger then tells you to let go of the anger. "Saturn ascends.. ultimatum prison cell." When the grudge descends on you have a choice... to feel the anger and hold on to that feeling.. and imprison yourself. Or "be humbled again" and let go of the anger... give away the stone if you will. Again.. like all of their songs the listener feels alot of emotion.. not just through the lyrics but the tone of music can give away what a verse might be trying to say.. ecspecially in Tool's case.
-
I think That this song Refers to 'the faithful' (Abrahamic religions) jealously and desperately clinging on to religious principals.
"Wear the grudge like a crown
Of negativity
Calculate what you will
Will not tolerate
Desperate to control
All and everything
Unable to forgive
Your scarlet letterman"
--Describing the self assumed rightousness and self interest of "the faithful". Then mentioning being "unable fo forgive your scarlet letterman", presumably refering to the First Council of Nicaea or the Book of Common Prayer and therefore the bearers of Christianity.
"Clutch it like a cornerstone
Otherwise it all comes down
Justify denials and
Grip 'em to the lonesome end
Clutch it like a cornerstone
Otherwise it all comes down
Terrified of being wrong
Ultimatum prison cell"
--Decribing clinging on to the organised religion for fear of loss of rightousness and self-denial of wrongdoing.
"Saturn ascends
Choose one or ten
Hang on or be
Humbled again
Humbled again"
--Saturn, in astrology, is associated with (among others) limitation, restriction and structures. The rise in negative emotion is also suggested.
This probably refers to the percieved collapse/ing of traditional religious beliefs and structures. Choosing one or ten, could be preposing that "the faithful" either cling on to orthodoxy and continue or accede to new ideas but be humbled for thier earlier ways. This is because saturn was traditionally considered the ruler of the first house but is considered ruler of the tenth house in modern astrology.
The rest of the song pretty much repeats the theme with slight variation until the end.
Towards the end, the lyrics extol allowing the religious beliefs to die and therefore allowing the rebirth and enlightenment to occur.
The return of saturn also signifying a turning point in someones life.
I think that the organised church (or the hierachy) could be the target or it could be the individual believer. Holding on to religion for fear of having to let it go and of being unknowing again. Knowing tool it seems likely to either, although in retrospect it seems more likely to be the individual since the theme of Lateralus is individual enlightenment and self-realisation.
More Tool songs »
Latest Articles
-
A new era for Millennial favorite, Linkin Park -
Anime to watch for the soundtracks… and other reasons you’re undateable -
.jpg)
Dolly, we need you -
The Stranger Things Effect: How new media is drawing Gen Z and Alpha's attention to aging media -
The most underrated soundtrack of the early 2000s -
Buy the Soundtrack, Skip the Movie: Brainscan (1994)
Trending:
Blog posts mentioning Tool
Anger, Hate, Rage: Music Best Suited to the Moment After Getting Fired
|
Just Posted
| Live Forever | anonymous |
| Space Oddity | anonymous |
| Remind You | anonymous |
| You've Got A Friend | anonymous |
| Austin | anonymous |
| Bel Air | anonymous |
| Firefly | anonymous |
| My Medicine | anonymous |
| Orphans | anonymous |
| Waka Waka (This Time for Africa) | anonymous |
| A Whole New World (End Title) | anonymous |
| Eyes Closed | anonymous |
| The Phrase That Pays | anonymous |
| Montreal | anonymous |
| Moonlight | anonymous |
